Wednesday, 8 April 2020

French Revolutionary Wars campaign, battle at Hondschoote, turns 6 to 14

Apologies for the delay in posting Part Two of this game (Part One ici ). Well, things are hotting up! In fact they hotted up, gone to boiling point and are now on a gentle simmer in the old pressure cooker of wargaming. It’s been exhausting just playing the game solo at a leisurely pace so I could send updates and photos to each of the players involved in the game from afar. I tried as a rule to only sent photos to the players of what they or their ADCs could actually see, mostly at horseback level, although one of the French commanders has spent much of the battle at the top of a windmill. I bet the French was regretting not deploying his Aerostatier Corps prior to this game.  No helicopter or hot air balloon views for the commanders in this game which I do think has proved to be rather frustrating, which was the objective. (Cue evil laugh).

Since the last post I’ve finished the game and played turns 6 to 14, taking us in 'Campaign Time to 6.30pm on 4 September 1793. As the game is over and the commanders are already aware of the result, normal ('ish) commentary will be resumed. I will prefix each caption with an E or a W to indicate which end of the table the action refers to. If you’ve not already done so, it might help to refresh your memory of the event that unfolded in turns 1 to 5 here .
E. French light infantry working their way around the open flank of the Hanoverian  Guard.
W. French grenadiers, supported by several battalions of ex-regulars, have taken the Hanoverian position and overrun their artillery.
E. Houchard's attack against the Eastern end of the village, defended by several Hanoverian battalions. The latter are seriously outnumbered.
W. Seen from the Hanoverian position, the French have occupied the captured earthwork and are forming up for  an attack across the road.
W. The same location but this time from the French perspective.

E. The Hanoverian cavalry brigade has forced the enemy into square but even charges against unformed and faltering squares were bounced.

W. Jourdan's heavy artillery advancing, but finding somewhere to deploy is an issue at the moment.

E. As the French legere battalions ease around the flank of the Hanoverian line, a battalion of Hessian grenadiers from the reserve moves to stop them, which it does.
E. The Hanoverian Guard were engaged in a lengthy musketry duel with French skirmishers and artillery and were being slowly worn down.
The brigade facing the Hanoverian Guard must retire soon as its battalions are all close to breaking.

W. On the other side of the village the one of Jourdan's less enthusiastic brigades prepares to assault the Hessians. 
W. The Hessian jager have dispersed the French skirmish screen but the brigade still advances.

W. The same scene from the Hessian perspective.


W. An assault across the road by one of Jourdan's brigades is repulsed. The leading French battalion disperses due to  casualties.
W Jourdan's horse artillery has run out of targets as the dastardly Hanoverians are hiding behind the raised causewof the road.
W. Hessians holding the barricade across the road where Jourdan's attack yesterday faltered.
W. French skirmishers, the survivors of the brigade skirmish screen, take pot shots at the Hessian battery.
W. Hessian jager lurking in the undergrowth.

W. Jourdan's troop poised to attack the Hessians.

E. Meanwhile on the other side of Hondschoote Houchards division is pressing hard to overwhelm the outnumbered Hanoverians facing them. What the French didn't know at first was they were facing the Hanoverian Guards.
E. The Hanoverian Guards slowly being whittled down holding back the French, who are also attempting to  edge past their open left flank.
The Guards giving the French a pasting.
Finally after several hours of dithering Jourdan's cavalry brigade joined the fray.
French and Hanoverians face off across the road. The causeway is high enough to prevent either side seeing the other unless one elects to shoot.
E. The fictitious Polish Legion of the North supports the attack on the town.

E. Houchard's legere battalions have suffered badly. One battalion has already broken and can be seen the one on the right already carries nine hits!
Houchard's cavalry also make an appearance, and their attached horse artillery races forward to engage the Guards.

W. Looking from the North. The Hessian brigade holding the road leading northwards out of Hondschoote.
The Representative of the People urges two battalions of volunteers to attack down the road, still carpeted with the French dead from yesterday's failed attack.
E. Houchard's dragoons take advantage of a dicey situation for the Guards. The Guards failed their Discipline Test so were unable to form square. Battered and unformed they were ridden down!
E. A rather pointless advance by the Hanoverian Lifeguard sees of the Polish skirmish screen but makes no impression on the square.
E. Sadly an exposed Polish battalion was charged in the rear by Hanoverian cavalry and broken. To be honest I'd forgotten about this battalion as they'd shimmied off to the left to avoid more punishing fire from the Guards. They were ridden down.
W. On the road the Volunteers survive a truly awful volley from the Hessians and make it into contact. They force their way over the barricades and push the Hessians back into the town.

W. Jourdan takes a chance and attacks the Hessian fusiliers exposed on the wrong side of the hedge. The French are forced to retreat with heavy casualties.
E. Meanwhile the victorious Hanoverian cavalry get to 'Charge On!' and hit another battalion of Poles, breaking them also. Sadly for the Hanoverians this puts them too close to Houchard's artillery who blow them to Kingdom Come the following turn. Back in the box!
E. The victorious French dragoons also charged on into the flank of the second Guards battalion, who are miraculously also ridden down.
E. They repeat the trick against the final battalion in the now much reduced brigade, who were formed up behind half completed gabions and easy prey for another flank attack. The Hanoverians are broken and the entire Guards Brigade has been destroyed.

W. Jourdan charges the Hessian battery.
W. Despite heavy casualties to the French the battery is overrun and the guns captured.
W. Another attack against the Hessian fusiliers gets into contact but fails to make any impression on the enemy.
E. Houchard looks on, making good use of the windmill to get a better view.
W. The Hussars du Mort charged recklessly across the road into a retreating Hanoverian battalion and rode over it.
W. In the same turn the two volunteer battalions, flush with their successful charge down the road turned onto the flank of the Hanoverians. One battalion failed and was dispersed, while the other forced their opponent to retire.
W. The Hessians have pulled back behind the hedge as the loss of the battery caused them to be faltering. Luckily they were forced to retreat, but they didn't break.
E. French horse artillery cover the withdrawal of two brigades of French infantry , or what was left of them.
The Hanoverian infantry brigade threw low so it was Sauve qui Peut for them! Covered by  Hanoverian cavalry.
The victorious Hussars du Mort. Weren't going to risk anything silly at this stage.

I called the game at that point. I'd played 14 turns over three days, and it went pretty well and was actually really good fun. Both armies were terribly battered thanks to a stout defence by the Hanoverians and some unlucky dice rolls for mainly the French but also for their foes. Again we had turns where the availability of ADCs was almost zero, and some horrible shooting dice (or great if you were the target) left the enemy unscathed. It was clearly a French victory but they were in no fit state to pursue. Two of Houchard's brigades were demoralised, and another had each of its battalions down to the last hit they could take before running. The Volunteer battalions were pretty untouched, likewise the cavalry and the artillery, but the cavalry didn't pursue as they were busy looking the Hanoverian Guards' tents and billets. Joubert had a faltering brigade and another that had been faltering on two occasions during the game but had come through both tests ok. It was fragile to say the least. Joubert's cavalry was still a force to contend with although not against Hanoverian cavalry even after this battle, but his artillery had taken some punishment, especially that caused by throwing really low several times and racking up approx 4 fatigue casualties on the horse company alone!

Given the state of the armies.....well I can't really say without giving even more secrets away, other than to say the French were in no fit state to pursue especially when the Hanoverian cavalry was almost intact. By comparison to the French brigades referred to above, the Hanoverians only had their cavalry under orders and and in good shape. The Hessians had to withdraw North off the table, which they did except for one battalion that was captured en masse in Hondschoote. The Hanoverian brigade withdrew south'ish covered by the cavalry, and no doubt joined by survivors from the Guards.  The French plan was sound but things just didn't roll their way enough, and the Hanoverian (& Hessian) defence was solid, until it all just crumbled at one.  For added fun I diced for commanders to see if anything happened to them during the rout/retreat. This resulted in the Hanoverian General Diepenbruck and the Hessian von Buttlar coming to sticky ends while the Duke of Cambridge, commanding the Hanoverian Guards, had been captured when his command ran away. None of the French were lost as they didn't do any pursuing.

Many thanks to the players for being on hand to respond to my emailed sit reps, questions and photos each turn.  It worked really well and I definitely felt that I wasn't just playing it solo by myself. I hope the photos and the narrative made enough sense to follow the game and anyone reading this will have enjoyed the experience.

Throughout the battle I was also feeding the relevant French commanders and the Anglo-Hanoverians and other Coalition commanders of other stuff "brewing" in their locale. For example, the French garrison in Dunkirk made a sortie to upset the English left to hold the almost complete siege works.

In campaign terms we have by the time this is published, started on September 5th. Some interesting developments and trouble brewing in a few places...... (cue evil laugh).

This is the summary to be found on the back outer cover of the book. 

The book re-evaluates both the plug bayonet as a weapon and its implementation which fundamentally changed how it impacted both the formation and tactics of all armies of the long seventeen century. The plug bayonets reputation was marred by General Hugh Mackay following his defeat at the Battle of Killiekrankie on the 27th July 1689 when he supposedly stated: ‘his men were defeated by an unforeseen technical flaw in their weaponry [plug bayonet]’. This view of the plug bayonet has been re-iterated constantly over the following 300 years, with military historian’s sideling the plug bayonet as a dead-end technology with little to commend it. While the introduction of the bayonet was a monumental step in the development of infantry in infantry tactics from pike to shot, one chapter will look at some of the other important developments with military technology. It will look at the arguments of matchlock vs flintlock and how they developed, and the introduction of Chevaux de frise, etc. It will prove that unlike some previous assertions, advancements within this sphere were not linier in nature. I will show that the adoption of the bayonet or the re-adoption of the pike were down to individual regimental colonel’s perception of these weapons, and in some cases the overall general in charge of specific operations. The following chapter investigates the changes within infantry battalion drill’s and organisation. How foot battalions went from up to one third of all soldiers armed only with defensive weapons (the pike) to battalions fully armed with both offensive and defensive weapons, the musket with bayonet. This development increased the firepower of any one battalion by up to one third, a step which was as a direct consequence of the introduction of the plug bayonet. The book will show that the plug bayonet was not only in use with English forces during the Dunkirk campaign in the early 1660’s, but the English establishment bought into the idea of the plug bayonet earlier than previously thought and placed large orders from the 1670’s, with the Board of Ordnance ordering 10,000 plug bayonets in 1678. Additionally, it will show that contemporary privately printed drill manuals are a valuable and accurate tool for identifying changes in military drill. It will identify how issues of supply and demand affected both English and continental armies. This is the first book whose primary focus is on the plug bayonet and its lasting impact on military tactics and equipment. The book will highlight that a piece of technology, which was derived from a civilian hunting weapon developed to hunt boar’s during the 16th century, that was still in use as such in Spain and Germany in the 19th century, transferred to an important piece of military equipment. As such, the plug bayonet was in use with the English army from c1660 until after 1700, being in use for over 40 years of service and as such does not deserve its reputation as a failure."

Well, what can I say? This is a scholarly are very well written and referenced piece of work. Mark's almost clinical research provides the reader with an excellent, and sometimes contrary to present day common thoughts, insight into the use and development of the plug bayonet. It also goes on to explain how the plug bayonet impacted on the development of the army as a whole. The more controversial conclusions are argued well and certainly shine a new light on the subject but I will leave the reader to judge for themselves. As a publication Helion has yet again added a superb book to their Century of the Soldier series. Plug bayonets is a bit of a niche subject, but as the author states, these weapons were an important aspect of the evolution of weapons and tactics in the period covered. The book is well laid out, well written, has an excellent bibliography, and is packed with 44 black and white illustrations, some of examples of plug bayonets still in existence now in private or public collections, others contemporary prints, and some specially commissioned line drawings. Of course being part of the Century of the Soldier series means that we are also blessed with eight pages of the usual glorious colour illustrations, including five by renowned artist Patrice Courcelle. I especially liked the colour photos of a rather grumpy looking re-enactor demonstrating the numerous drills for using a plug bayonet. To top it all is the chapter entitled The English Army, which covers everything from organisation and structure, strengths, pay, soldiers' care and a mass of information shown in tabular form about the dispersal of the English army in billets around the Kingdom. Indeed  the book is full of very handy tables to support the narrative, as well as several pages detailing the regiments and their strengths at various times during the period covered by the book which I'm sure will be invaluable to anyone gaming the wars of the late 17th century. Great stuff. An excellent book and highly recommended. 

Tuesday, 7 April 2020

Precautions.

They’re selling out fast!

Some ADCs for General d'Armée

Since starting to use Gen d'Armée its been fun painting up extra figures to use as ADCs in the games. Now, they only appear so to speak for a very little time each turn but visually I think a suitable figure is better than a rather bland marker that looks like, well, for the shortsighted amongst us, just another marker. So here are a few completed or almost completed ADCs.

A Representative of the People. Not strictly an ADC but if present with a brigade commander he gets a re-roll for activation. If with the CinC he gives a re-roll on a single failed ADC roll. Not in the main rules but why not? I just need to finish his assistant, who is of course taking copious notes.
On the left we have an officer of HM 15th Light dragoons (IIRC), a Foundry figure. On the right one of my favourite figures, an officer of the Hanoverian 10th Light Dragoons, is this Hinchliffe one piece casting that must be over 40 years old. 

Here are two Revolutionary French ADCs. On the left a Dragoon officer but I don't know the makers. On the right thins I think a Dixon figure but with a new sword arm and horse, painted as an officer of the 7eme Hussars in undress uniform.


A bit of light relief as I plough through the last of the French Revolutionary Wars figures currently on the paint station of hell. Still plenty in the box of doom though!