Sunday, 18 July 2021

More awesomeness from M. Chartrand - Armies and Wars of the Sun King Volume IV

 




I’m not going to fill this review with superlatives just for the sake of it, but I will use a few, sparingly if needs be.

BEAUTIFUL! That’s what this book is in one word. The fourth and final volume in Rene Chartrand’s almost forensic analysis of the Armies and Wars of the Sun King 1643-1715 covers the War of the Spanish Succession, artillery, engineers and the militias. Helion have published a blinder here, No. 70 in their excellent’Century of the Soldier’ series. Like the preceding three books in this series, this one is the result of painstaking research using a vast range of primary and secondary sources, and it needs its 280-odd pages to give the subject matter justice.

As is my normal expectation with Helion publications, the book contains 32 pages of colour plates, a mixture of specially commissioned work by Ed Dovey, a couple of classic Bob Marrions, and reproductions of earlier works by artists such as Marbot and Delaitre. What with photos of French fortress models and some flags, the colour section is vibrant and really sets the book off; and of course there are a gazzillion black and white mostly contemporary illustrations as well, spread liberally through its pages. There are also some useful maps that tie in well with the narrative.

As the title suggests, the author uses the first half of the book to outline the origins of the War of the Spanish Succession and the course of the war itself in every theatre. The narrative here is well written and gives us a clear if necessarily truncated account of the war, personalities, key moments, battles, sieges etc, and the impact it had on the rest of Europe both during hostilities and at its conclusion.

The other half of the book moves on nicely to the engineers, artillery and militia, and the remaining sections describe the organisation of the French artillery, their uniforms, history and roles of the different types be they field, fortress or coastal. There’s an interesting chapter on engineers, sieges and fortresses in war and then we’re treated to a description of territorial command staff, light troops, gentlemen-cadets, armed constabulary, local reserve troops ad the myriad of different types of militia or civic guards that could be found across France during this period. Each of these militia-type units is described, with their organisation, uniforms and main activities during our period. I would never have imagined that these second, third, fourth or even fifth-line troops could be so diverse in their nature, make up and uniforms, and the information we have presented to us must be the result of some intense and deep amount of research. Finally there are chapters on what are perhaps oddly always my favourite subjects, the human side of this study of the army, through a description of the organisation in place for caring for the bodies and souls of soldiers and on the lives of soldiers’ families, which as ever highlight the trials and tribulations of soldiering during this period. It doesn’t end there as the appendices run off the book with sections on the Bourbon Spanish army of King Filipe V, its dress, organisation and order of battle and last of all a section outlining the Portuguese army of the period.

I wholeheartedly recommend this book, it might even be my favourite of the four. I would say that the is a must for anyone interested in the armies and reign of The Sun King. It is an absolute mine of information, is clearly presented and well written and if you’ve not read the earlier volumes then you should buy them now. I can also see me scrabbling through my scraps box to make up a couple of tiny militia-type units just for the hell of it.

Friday, 16 July 2021

The Bavarian Army of the Thirty Years War 1618-1648 Revised Edition

This second edition of The Bavarian Army of the Thirty Years War by Laurence Spring benefits not only from revised text, but a fair amount of additional information as well as 16 pages of colour illustrations, depicting flags, both newly drawn by Matz Elzinga, or photos of originals, together with six pages of super colour illustrations of various troop types  by Sergey Shamenkov. As such it is a much improved piece of work covering in great detail the often overlooked participant in the Thirty Years War, and what the book calls ‘the backbone of the Catholic League’, Bavaria. 





What do we get? Well, a very in depth study of every aspect of the army, including recruitment, through to dress, weapons, organisation, training and supply. I particularly liked the chapters on the militia and on life and death in the army. In terms of the latter it must have been tough and harrowing at times. The example of the unexplained death of some horses being blamed on some soldiers’ wives who were accused, tried and burned for witchcraft is certainly evidence of summary justice at its worst! Monty Python eat your heart out!


The Appendices are especially enlightening. Of these, the first is description of the wonderful 400-year old collection of flags in the Swedish Army Museum, and the second gives us a run down on every regiment that served in the Bavarian army, it’s commanders, actions it took part in and it’s ultimate fate, which is a fascinating subject in its own right for the likes of me. The other appendices give details of all the Protestant colours captured and a break down of the strengths of the various militia companies.


Overall then, I enjoyed this revised edition far more than the original, and not just because of the pictures I hasten to add! It’s just more of a finished work and well worth buying, even if you do have the original.



Thursday, 15 July 2021

The Military History of Late Rome, 361-395

 

 


Being ‘in’ to Late Romans during the latter part of the fourth century at the moment I was very excited when I saw this volume by Finnish historian Dr. Ilkka Syvanne. I bit the bullet and bought the rather pricey hardback version of this book rather than the e-version. It is one of a series of an ambitious and tempting series books covering the period from 284-641, but a £30 a pop I won’t rush out to buy the rest just yet. (Note to self: put them on the Santa List). 


The book covers in quite some detail the Roman Empire (both Eastern and Western) at the beginning of the period covered by this book, ie from AD 361, with an interesting discussion on the army, the fleet and organisation and tactics. What’s described doesn’t quite match with my understanding from other reading of how the Roman army was organised or how it fought but I’m by no means an expert in the subject. Nevertheless it’s interesting and helpful in affirming a fair bit about what I know.  


We then get sections, some too brief perhaps, covering all the various barbarian, and more civilised but still barbaric Sassanids, to be found outside and sometimes within Rome’s borders. A useful overview for sure and a helpful primer for further reading. My ‘barbarian’ interests lie with the Ostrogoths and Visigoths, Vandals, Huns and Sassanids and I can’t complain about the content. Again it may differ slightly from other stuff I’ve read but then,the question arises of “do we really know?” I mean, while I am by no means an army list savant or slave I’ve always found them either interesting, helpful or bloody nonsense (delete as applicable). Take the Goths for example, they’re depicted differently in each of five different so-called army lists I have access to! 


I digress. The chapters on the Emperor Julian the Apostate, Jovian, Valentinian and Theodosius are all fascinating and for me very useful, especially the campaigns against the Sassanids, the destruction of the Emperor Valens’ army at Adrianople by theGoths and the struggles the Empire had from internal and external forces throughout this period. It’s obviously a very deeply researched book, with a lengthy bibliography and more than a few handy maps. There are a goodly number of black and white drawings depicting various troop types. What the book lacks are some colour illustrations, but that’s perhaps just my preference. Sadly, although it’s generally well written (and sympathetically translated assuming it was written in Finnish originally) there are far too many errors and clunky chunks of text which to me are like a red rag to a bull. These errors don’t spoil the book from a content perspective but do from a quality one. I strongly believe that all authors should an produce ‘oven ready’ manuscript if the number of copy editors with severe anxiety disorders is to be kept down. 


Overall then, I’m certainly not unhappy with the book, indeed I’m pleased with the fact I went for the hard copy. As I said earlier, at the present price I doubt I’ll be buying the other five (I think) volumes in the series any time soon, but I’d be interested to hear from more knowledgeable people than me on how correct the actual content is. I think as an introduction to what is a pretty massive subject it does it’s job well.


These are the other books in the series.









Remains of General Gudin returned to France from Russia.

This popped up randomly on my browser today. Interesting.


https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-57810139.amp 

Sunday, 11 July 2021

Goth Parade






Not a parade of the entire army as such but just the cavalry. Three weeks ago I foolishly said on Facebook that I'd finish 48 Goth cavalry (six units) in a week. No surprise to me or anyone on the planet that I missed that goal by a mile, but I'm pleased to report that the last unit was completed this morning. I've managed to double the number of Goth cavalry I now have available, with 12 units in total. They look pretty menacing. 


Also shown are two new commanders, one for the Goths and a lone Late Roman.

Carry on at the Apiary

 


I came across these when surfing the net at stupid o'clock one day last week. Mmm? I thought, they'd look nice on the table as a little vignette thingy. They're from Midlam Miniatures and a rather nice I reckon. Oddly, I ordered both the male and female beekeepers and some hives, but received more of the latter than I'd requested. They must have been freebies! Aaargh that was bad.

Anyway, despite the rather average paint job (completed over the course of a couple of days using contract paints while other stuff dried) I like them. And they will do their bit tending the bees across many a battlefield and century.

Friday, 2 July 2021

Italian Wars game with Sword and Spear and a cute kitten


Catzilla or Kitten Kong?

A rather belated post this week, as I’ve been quite busy on real life stuff. On Saturday gone I hosted an Italian Wars game. While they can give a good game when played sensibly, ie play the period not the rules, and use a well researched army rather than what the manufacturer sells, I’ve never been entirely (!) happy with Pike and Shotte. Although they’re fine if played with at least a nod to history,  I have yet to find any other set that really floats my gondola for the Italian Wars, but there are some unofficial Italian Wars amendments to Sword and Spear that have been floated on their forum so it was suggested we should adapt them and try them out. I’ll put the army lists at the end of the post if I remember. It was going to be interesting to see how the rules coped with my huge pike blocks.

We threw dice to see who would be on each side. Steve (Papal), Paul (Spanish/Neapolitan) and Nigel (Florentine) were under over command of Neil, while Conrad and I were the French and Mike the Swiss. The French were outnumbered considerably in men and by about 20 percent in combined strength points, but they had some better troops (Swiss and Gendarmes)…..and some far worse (the native French infantry) than the Spanish/Papal/Florentine army.


The road running along the length of the battlefield towards the unnamed city.
Life still goes on in the city streets.
The protagonists. French on the right.
The main Papal contingent, a mass of fearsome Landsknechts and fearful Italian pikemen. 

Nobody expected the Spanish Inquisition!

The Papal Landsknechts advance against the French left.

Mike’s Swiss pike blocks surge towards Nigel’s Florentine’s.

In an act of futile self sacrifice Nigel’s Condottieri gendarmes charged the Swiss mass. Unsurprisingly they did a good impression of a speed bump.

Florentine militia look on as their Condottieri comrades are about to  bounce off the Swiss. “Us next I think” is the thought undoubtedly in their minds.

The Swiss reach the Florentine gun line and overrun their artillery.

Meanwhile the Papal forces have brought along their cheerleading team!

In the centre the Spanish infantry make short work of the French crossbowmen.

Spanish and Neapolitan gendarmes in the centre.


Sorry but I like the look of all these Swiss!

The Papal forces vastly outnumbered my French and marched through a large gap in our line. However, my gendarmes were making short work of the Papal gendarmes out of shot to the left.

Conrad’s French pike and crossbows in our thinly held centre.

Spanish gendarmes crash into the French pike but miraculously bounce off.
                             
More Spanish gendarmes have a go against the French to no effect. It’ll be left for the Papal Landsknechts to roll up the French hitting them in the flank next turn.Esme is having a sleep on the table while the battle rages.
Nigel’s surviving gendarmes crash into the flank of one of Mike’s Swiss pike blocks.
                             
French gendarmes breaking through the enemy right wing.
                     
Conrad’s French gendarmes locked in combat with Paul’s Spanish colonellas in the centre,  successfully halting their advance.

The Papal commander somewhat put on a limb as his infantry has outpaced him or been driven off and his cavalry have all fled.
The Papal flank has been crushed (ok I am ignoring the Landsknechts and Papal pikemen that have pushed right through to roll up our centre), about to capture the enemy camp.

One of the Papal pike blocks unable to move in the centre of the table near the French camp.
                          
The Papal Landsknechts about to roll up our centre. This they did but it took longer than might have been expected.
French gendarmes about to pounce on the rear of the Spanish and Neapolitan gendarmes engaged in the centre.

Well, that went really well. The amendments worked nicely such as they were. Everyone picked the rules up or remembered them within a couple of turns and a great game was fought out to a conclusion. Certainly felt like a satisfying game. More so than Pike and Shotte? Undoubtedly.

When I remembered to do a quick tally, the French were at the point of all units needing to take a discipline test, but the Spanish/Papal/Florentine alliance has lost over 50% of their strength points so we’re forced to concede. It’d been a close game. Our centre was crushed, the Swiss destroyed much of the enemy left but had become bogged down (one block had even been destroyed!) and my left wing had driven off all the Papal cavalry, was  rolling up the enemy flank and was within striking distance of the rear of the Spanish in the centre. I think we could safely argue for French victory even without the count up of lost points. Man of the match was definitely Esme, who played a blinder chasing dice and terrorising the inhabitants of the city and the troops of both sides without fear or favour.


Here are the orders of battle and stats used. Thanks to Neil for his input with these.

FRENCH                                      Discipline/Strength/Armour/Weapon



Commander:


Swiss:

One unit of Swiss pike HF 3/6/Sw/Pikes+2HW*/Large unit

Two units of Swiss pike HF 3/8/Sw/Pikes+2HW*/Huge unit

One unit of Swiss crossbowmen LF 4/2/Av/Crossbow*

Two units of Swiss shot LF 4/2/Av/Arquebus*

*All Swiss units are Steadfast.


Centre:

Two units of French Gendarmes d’Ordinance Cav 3/4/HA/Impact/Undrilled

Two units of French pike HF 5/4/Sw/Pikes

One unit French Arquebusiers MF 5/4/Av/Arquebus

Two units of Gascon/Norman Crossbowmen MF 4/3/Pavises/Crossbow

One unit of Gascon/Norman Crossbowmen MF 4/5/Pavises/Crossbow/Large

Heavy guns in battery Art 4/3/Av/Guns



Left:

Two units of French Gendarmes d’Ordinance Cav 3/4/HA/ Impact/Undrilled

One unit of Condottieri Gendarmes Cav 4/3/HA/Impact

Two units of French Argoulets LH 4/2/Av/Arquebus

One unit Stradiots LH 4/2/Av/Jav

Light guns in battery Art 4/2/Av/Guns


Pikes+2HW* - If the unit is fresh and has not moved this phase, has an action dice allocated, and was charged and contacted frontally by enemy pike, it causes an automatic discipline test on the enemy unit before the combat is resolved. The unit may still use the action dice to gain impetus as normal. If it is fresh and has made an advance this phase, it may choose to get the same effect, but it must give up one impetus dice to do so.


Large (or Huge) pike blocks fired on by artillery count as Lacking Protection.



Crossbows - 16” range. Heavily armoured or armoured target reduced by one level or protection.

Arquebus - 12” range. Ignores all armour.

Light Guns - 24” range. Can move 4” in Open terrain.


HOLY LEAGUE OF LAMBRATE GHISA Discipline/Strength/Armour/Weapon


Commander:

Vanguard:

One unit of Condotieri gendarmes Cav 4/3/HA/Impact

One unit of Lanza Spezzia Gendarmes Cav 4/3/HA/Impact/Undrilled

Two units of Jinettes LH 4/2/Av/Javelins

One unit of Italian mounted crossbows LH 4/2/Av/Crossbow

One unit Italian mounted arquebusiers LH 4/2/Av/Arquebus

One unit Italian heavy infantry HF 5/4/HA/2HW

Two units of Italian crossbows LF 5/2/Av/Crossbow

Light guns in battery Art 4/2/Av/Guns



Papal Division:

One Landsknecht pike HF 4/8/Sw/Pikes+2HW*/Huge unit

One unit of Landsknecht shot LF 4/2/Av/Arquebus

One unit of Papal Casa/Famiglia gendarmes Cav 3/3/HA/Impact/Undrilled

One unit of Condottieri gendarmes Cav 3/3/HA/Impact

Two units of Italian mounted arquebusiers LH 4/2/Av/Arquebus

Two units of Italian pike HF 5/4/Sw/Pikes

Two units Papal arquebusiers LF 4/2/Av/Arquebus

Light guns in battery Art 4/2/Av/Guns



Spain/Naples:

One unit of Spanish gendarmes Cav 3/3/HA/Impact/Undrilled

Two units of Neapolitan Lanza Spezia Cav 4/3/HA/Impact/Undrilled

Spanish Colunella:

Four units of HF 3/4/HA/Pikes+2HW*/Arquebus#

Neapolitan Militia Archers LF 5/2/LP/Short bow

Medium guns in battery Art 4/2/Av/Guns

=



Pikes+2HW* - If the unit is fresh and has not moved this phase, has an action dice allocated, and was charged and contacted frontally by enemy pike, it causes an automatic discipline test on the enemy unit before the combat is resolved. The unit may still use the action dice to gain impetus as normal. If it is fresh and has made an advance this phase, it may choose to get the same effect, but it must give up one impetus dice to do so.


# arquebus are in front rank. If contact made with the enemy and they have been allocated a dice then they pass through to the rear of the pikes. If caught then the unit does not get pike/2HW bonus.



Large (or Huge) pike blocks fired on by artillery count as Lacking Protection.



Crossbows - 16” range. Heavily armoured or armoured target reduced by one level or protection.

Arquebus - 12” range. Ignores all armour.

Light Guns - 24” range. Can move 4” in Open terrain.

NOTES:



Steadfast – The unit does not take discipline tests as a result of:

· Friendly units routing.

· Commanders being killed.

· Army morale test.

Additionally, the unit does not suffer the normal discipline penalty for being out of command.

Sw – Shieldwall. Treated as armoured if fresh and either in melee or shot at by a unit which is in front of it (i.e., Part of the shooting unit is directly in front of the unit).

Large - It requires an action dice two higher than its discipline rating to carry out a manoeuvre. It cannot move backwards, although it can carry out a 180° turn as a manoeuvre.

Undrilled - It requires an action dice two higher than its discipline rating to carry out a manoeuvre.

Pavises – The unit is treated as armoured if it is either in melee and is fresh or is shot at by a unit which is in front of it (i.e., Part of the shooting unit is directly in front of the unit with pavises). Otherwise, it is treated as lacking protection. The movement rate of the unit is reduced by 1 DU (4”). 2HW - A unit armed with two handed weapons ig